pleasures are different like colours
also you are right. a photographer (Ara Güler) said: "modern photography is not an art i think. because people using photoshop and lots of other things. so this photograps are not the truth of life."
Boy did that guy open a can of worms.
Photoshop whether someone likes it or not is Art in and of itself. It would be one thing to say that you don't like heavily manipulated photo's to draw a line in the sand and suggest that putting your work through Photoshop means that you are destroying your art is just crazy talk. I maintain that there is not a real money making photographer out there that does not "fix" their shots after the fact.
And if you guys are talking about the first shot being fake then you are right. The scene would never really look that way to your eye but are you really saying that it is wrong to use your photographic vision to create something using some techniques? Mine is not fake looking. If you stood there and looked at that scene without rapidly blinking your eyes, (fast shutter), that is a pretty fair representation of what you would see. The smoothness of the water is a bit exaggerated but everywhere that you see the water smooth did indeed have smooth white water.